
2009 Toyota Avalon XL - Zumbrota, Minn. Photo by Randy Stern
Ageism. Even in my mid-forties, I get some of it. Sometimes I get it in jest; other times with intent to demean yours truly.
One such event of ageism through jest came with a discussion of whether a friend in Janesville, Wisconsin wants to replace his Pontiac Grand Prix GXP for a Chevrolet Traverse crossover. When I suggested that he also look at the Buick Enclave, the upscale version of the Traverse, he rejected the idea based on the stereotypical demographic the brand attracts. He even said that I was a part of said demographic…in jest, of course.
I wasn’t entirely offended. I know I’m getting older, but I also know that I have respect for Buicks over the decades. I’ll even offer up that I know many people of all ages who either own Buicks and had one before…and enjoyed them. No matter how soft, cushy and pillowy their driving manners were, Buicks spoke to the type of driver who wants to not care about the world around them.
The Buick LeSabre, since replaced by the thoroughly advanced Lucerne, was a prime example of what a Buick stood for. It was big, comfortable and no one cared how it drove or what kind of fuel economy it turned.
Ah, but I pointed out that several competitors were able to create their own Buicks. Some of them built and drive better than one! The Hyundai Azera is one example of an entry-premium sedan geared towards the former Buick LeSabre owner looking for a trade-in. I pointed out how much the Azera felt much more in tune with drivers that care about tighter rides and better handling in their large sub-$32,000 sedans.
However, there is the Toyota Avalon. Since Toyota wanted to reach out to North American consumers by giving them a lineup that spoke to every kind of automobile owner, the Avalon became the LeSabre of the lineup. After a few generations, they succeeded in improving upon the LeSabre.
Whenever I talk about big comfortable sedans, I use a very American sedan as a measuring stick: The Chevrolet Impala. Enthusiasts would dismiss the big Chevy as something to match a Toyota with, but for a guy who loves to cruise down in a large comfortable sedan around The Cities and beyond…this makes sense.
So, has the big Avalon matched the Impala? You betcha! In some cases, it even surpasses it!
Before we get into the real comparisons, one thing must be said about the Avalon. Granted Toyota has some vehicles that are easy on the eyes, such as the Yaris hatchback and the RAV4. There are a couple that are, at best, iconic, such as the Prius and the Camry. Then, there are designs that fall flat on their face, keeping in mind that Toyota had always been known for being bland and conservative in their designs for a 15 year span until recently. Sadly, the Avalon employs some dubious angles and some gangly and large details. Some might say that there’s a degree of goofiness in the Azera, some overly ambitious curves on the Nissan Maxima, a gangsta vibe in the Chrysler 300 and that the Lucerne is too elongated for its own purpose. In all, you might say that you simply do not buy an entry-premium sedan for its looks.
Inside is something of a vision Toyota had for a Buick. There are plenty of familiar Toyota details mixed with some interesting wide-body cabin features. The blue screen (not to be confused with Microsoft Windows’ infamous “blue screen of death”) gives a mix of reading for the climate control, audio system, weather and fuel consumption information. However, the driving position is similar to the Azera’s: Tall with a low cowl. This is fine even for someone who prefers his instrumentation right in front of him. The seats are big, but give you the right mix of comfortable and firm. It makes driving more important from this vantage point.
Where it makes me smile is everything else on the Avalon. My 2009 XL model, sitting at the entry point of Toyota’s largest sedan, starts off with a powerful, quiet and familiar 3.5litre V6 employing 268HP. This is connected to a 6-speed automatic that is smooth in going through the gears and getting the big car rolling along the highway. This car has a supple and smooth ride…just the way I like it! You should not be reminded that this is an extended Camry chassis with a completely different shell. It’s handling is a bit off, but I blame that on a softer suspension set and the 16-inch wheels employed on the base XL. I was informed that the tauter Touring model from last year was nixed for 2009. In all, it stops superbly.
The biggest surprise was the steering, perhaps the tightest of any big car I have ever driven. Want to make a u-turn? No problem. It does it smoothly and swiftly without wondering if you’ll hit a curb.
If you’re concerned about fuel economy, you may want to skip this paragraph. Still, the big V6-powered Toyota Avalon still turned a 23.7MPG loop. Not bad for a big sedan.
Before I conclude on the Avalon, there are a couple of related observations to make. Mind you I did not mention anything about the Buick Lucerne. Not that I have yet to drive one, but to acknowledge that it raised the bar for Buick. I must point out that even the Lucerne will be eclipsed two fold: If not by the Enclave, then by the 2010 LaCrosse/Allure.
Yet, I’ve been fortunate to drive a lot of different Toyotas this year. A common thread with each Toyota has been the solid foundation where familiar components, sounds and functionality are of the highest level of satisfaction. Yet, there are some Toyotas I would be happy to drive again above other models in the lineup.
The Avalon is one of them.